Best Sandwiches in San Diego: Top 5 Must-Try Spots
San Diego’s sandwich scene is as vibrant and diverse as the city itself. From fresh-off-the-boat seafood to smoky, slow-roasted meats and inventive vegetarian creations, there’s a sandwich here for every craving. Whether you’re a local on the hunt for a new lunch spot or a visitor eager to taste the city’s best, these five sandwich shops stand out for their quality, flavor, and local love.
Here’s our guide to the best sandwiches in San Diego you can’t miss in 2025.
Let’s explore each sandwich shops in more details
1. El Pescador – La Jolla
- Must-Try: El Pescador Sandwich – Dungeness crab, shrimp, smoked salmon, lettuce, tomato, onion, and tartar sauce on sourdough.
Nestled in the heart of La Jolla, just steps from stunning beaches, El Pescador has been serving fresh fish sandwiches for over 40 years. The seafood here comes directly from local fishermen and trusted suppliers, ensuring every bite is fresh and flavorful.
Why it’s the best: Known for its generous seafood portions and unbeatable freshness, this is a must for seafood lovers.
- 📍 Location: 634 Pearl St, La Jolla, CA 92037
- 💲 Price Range: Visit Site
- ⏰ Hours: Daily, 11 AM – 9 PM
🌐 Website: elpescadorfishmarket.com
2. Big Front Door (BFD) – Hillcrest
- Must-Try: L.G.B.T. – Lettuce, Gouda, bacon, Roma tomato, aioli, oil & vinegar on sourdough.
Affectionately called “BFD,” Big Front Door is a neighborhood deli famous for its in-house roasted and smoked meats. Their menu is a flavorful blend of Southern California influences, with plenty of hearty sandwiches and fresh salads.
Why it’s the best: The portions are big, the flavors bold, and the quality top-notch. Great for a quick grab-and-go or a relaxed lunch.
- 📍 Location: 4075 Park Blvd #101, San Diego, CA 92103
- 💲 Price Range: Visit Site
- ⏰ Hours: Daily, 10 AM – 6 PM
🌐 Website: bfdsandiego.com
3. The Deli Llama – Hillcrest
- Must-Try: Fire Eater Wrap – Turkey, pepper jack, fresh toppings, chipotle aioli in a spinach wrap.
Quirky and fun, The Deli Llama is loved for its creative sandwiches, friendly service, and playful atmosphere. Fan favorites include the spicy Fire Eater Wrap and the indulgent Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese Panini.
Why it’s the best: Perfect balance of creativity and comfort — plus, the staff make you feel like family.
- 📍 Location: 3702 Fifth Ave, San Diego, CA 92103
- 💲 Price Range: Visit Site
- ⏰ Hours: Mon–Sat 10:30 AM – 4 PM, Sun Closed
🌐 Website: delillamasd.com
4. The Cheese Shop – La Jolla Shores
- Must-Try: Turkey, Cranberry & Muenster – Homemade cranberry sauce, lettuce, tomato, rosemary bread.
A La Jolla Shores institution since 1972, The Cheese Shop has been delighting customers with hearty, old-school sandwiches for decades. Their house-roasted pork tenderloin with melted jack cheese is also a top seller.
Why it’s the best: Classic flavors, friendly vibes, and perfect picnic sandwiches for a beach day.
- 📍 Location: 2165 Avenida De La Playa, La Jolla, CA 92037
- 💲 Price Range: Visit Site
- ⏰ Hours: Daily, 8 AM – 4 PM
- 🌐 Website: cheeseshoplajolla.com
5. Deli-icious – La Jolla Village
- Must-Try: Turkey & Avocado Panini – Turkey breast, jack cheese, avocado, spicy mustard, mayo, pressed and grilled.
Since 1992, Deli-icious has been serving both cold and hot sandwiches, breakfast options, and fresh paninis. Their bacon, egg, and cheese breakfast sandwich is a morning favorite.
Why it’s the best: A hidden gem with a cozy feel and consistently delicious sandwiches.
- 📍 Location: 1237 Prospect St, Suite J, La Jolla, CA 92037
- 💲 Price Range: Visit Site
- ⏰ Hours: Mon–Friday 10 AM – 4 PM, Sun – Sat 10 AM – 5 PM
- 🌐 Website: deliicious.com
Quick Comparison: Best Sandwiches in San Diego
|
Shop Name |
Must-Try Sandwich |
Price Range |
Neighborhood |
|
El Pescador |
El Pescador Sandwich (seafood mix) |
Visit Site |
La Jolla |
|
Big Front Door |
L.G.B.T. |
Visit Site |
Hillcrest |
|
The Deli Llama |
Fire Eater Wrap |
Visit Site |
Hillcrest |
|
The Cheese Shop |
Turkey, Cranberry & Muenster |
Visit Site |
La Jolla |
|
Deli-icious |
Turkey & Avocado Panini |
Visit Site |
La Jolla |
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re chasing a freshly caught seafood sandwich by the beach or craving a warm, cheesy panini, San Diego’s sandwich shops have you covered. Each spot on this list delivers a unique experience and unforgettable flavor — so grab a friend, bring your appetite, and start your own sandwich tour of America’s Finest City.
